As a solopreneur, hiring help is a major step in growing your business. But before you bring someone on board, there’s one critical question you need to answer: Should you hire an employee or a contractor?
Getting this decision wrong can result in hefty fines, legal trouble, and IRS penalties. Misclassifying a worker can lead to back taxes, unpaid benefits, and even lawsuits. The last thing you want is to scale your business only to get hit with unexpected legal troubles.
To make the right choice, ask yourself these five key questions to determine whether you need an employee or a contractor—and how to stay compliant with labor laws.
How Much Control Do You Need Over Their Work?
One of the biggest differences between an employee and a contractor is control.
- Employees work under your direct supervision. You control their schedule, work methods, and performance.
- Contractors operate independently. They set their own hours, use their own tools, and complete work according to agreed terms.
Rule of Thumb: If you need someone to follow your processes and work under your instructions daily, they should likely be classified as an employee.
How Long Do You Need Their Help?
Consider the duration and consistency of the work:
- Long-term, ongoing role? You probably need an employee.
- Short-term, project-based work? A contractor may be the better fit.
Example: If you need an assistant to manage daily operations indefinitely, that’s an employee. If you only need a website designer to build your website, that’s a contractor.
Will You Provide Training and Equipment?
Another key difference is who supplies training, tools, and equipment:
- Employees rely on you for training, software, and work equipment.
- Contractors use their own tools, skills, and resources to complete the job.
Red Flag: If you’re training someone on how to do the work and providing all the tools, they may legally qualify as an employee, not a contractor.
How Will You Pay Them?
Your payment structure matters when determining classification:
- Employees are paid a consistent salary or hourly wage and receive payroll deductions (taxes, Social Security, Medicare, etc.).
- Contractors are paid per project or milestone and receive a flat fee or commission. No payroll taxes are withheld.
Important: If you’re paying someone regularly like an employee (e.g., weekly salary), the IRS may classify them as an employee, even if you label them as a contractor.
Are You Covering Benefits and Taxes?
Understanding tax obligations is crucial to avoid penalties:
- Employees are entitled to benefits like health insurance, paid time off, and workers’ compensation. You, as the employer, must also pay payroll taxes.
- Contractors handle their own taxes and don’t receive benefits from you.
IRS Warning: If the government determines you should have paid payroll taxes but didn’t, you could be liable for back taxes and fines.
Avoid Misclassification Fines—Get HR Support Today!
Choosing between an employee and a contractor can feel confusing, but misclassifying workers can cost you thousands in penalties.
💡 Need expert guidance? Don’t leave your business at risk. Schedule a 1:1 HR Consultation today to ensure you classify your workers correctly and stay compliant with labor laws.
Let’s build your business the right way—without legal headaches! 🚀
Ready to have MentorShelly help you structure your business SOPs? Go Here.
If you are looking for help in the overall job market, interview tips and more, purchase my new book here.
Connect with me here
Follow me here: Facebook | Instagram | YouTube | Join the Facebook Group |