CEO Fireside Chat™ – You Keep Hiring People Into Roles That Were Never Clearly Defined

Let’s get real, CEO.

You keep hiring people into roles that were never clearly defined—and then wondering why the employee is confused, the manager is frustrated, and the work is not getting done correctly.

The job posting said one thing. The interview suggested something else. The manager explained the role differently during onboarding.

And three months later, the employee is performing duties that were never discussed, measured, or documented. Then leadership concludes:

“They’re not taking initiative.”

“They’re not meeting expectations.”

“They just aren’t the right fit.”

But here is the uncomfortable question: Did the employee fail the role—or did the company fail to define it?

Because you cannot fairly hold someone accountable for expectations your leadership team never clearly established. Welcome to CEO Fireside Chat™, where we discuss the people decisions, operational weaknesses, and hidden HR risks growing businesses cannot afford to ignore.

Today, we are talking about what happens when companies hire first and define the role later.

Growth Has a Way of Creating “Patchwork Positions”

This problem is common in growing companies. When you had five employees, everyone did a little bit of everything. Somebody answered the phone, helped a customer, processed an invoice, ordered supplies, and handled whatever else needed to be done before lunch. That flexibility may have helped the business survive its early stages. What worked with five employees can create confusion, inefficiency, and exposure when you grow to 15, 25, 50, or 100 employees.

As the company expands, responsibilities are added without being formally assigned. Employees leave, and their duties are divided among whoever remains. Managers create new expectations without updating the job description. Leadership changes priorities, but nobody clarifies what should stop when new work is added.

Eventually, the company is not managing defined positions. It is managing a collection of tasks held together by memory, habit, and whoever knows how to get things done. That is not scalable workforce infrastructure. That is organizational duct tape.

A Job Title Is Not a Job Definition

Giving someone the title of “manager,” “coordinator,” “specialist,” or “administrator” does not explain what that person is responsible for accomplishing.

A clearly defined role should answer several important questions:

  • Why does this position exist?
  • What outcomes is the employee expected to produce?
  • What are the essential job functions?
  • Which responsibilities belong to this position?
  • Which responsibilities belong to someone else?
  • Who does the employee report to?
  • What decisions can the employee make independently?
  • Which matters must be escalated?
  • How will performance be measured?
  • What knowledge, skills, experience, and physical or operational requirements are genuinely necessary?

If leadership cannot answer those questions consistently, the employee probably cannot either.

And when the CEO, hiring manager, and employee each have a different understanding of the same position, conflict is not a surprise. It is a predictable outcome.

The Job Description and the Actual Job Are Often Two Different Things

Some companies have job descriptions, but they have not been reviewed in years. The document describes the position the company originally hired. The employee is performing the position the business eventually created.

That gap matters. Perhaps the employee was hired for customer service but now handles scheduling, billing, collections, inventory, and employee onboarding.

Perhaps the assistant manager is supervising employees, approving time, issuing corrective action, and responding to complaints—but the company still treats the role as if it has no meaningful decision-making authority.

Perhaps a salaried employee has a management title but spends most of the workweek performing the same routine tasks as hourly employees.

Perhaps a position allegedly requires lifting, travel, certain scheduling availability, or another qualification, but leadership cannot explain why that requirement is essential.

Your job descriptions should not be historical artifacts. They should reflect how work is actually being performed, who owns each responsibility, what authority accompanies the role, and how that role contributes to the business.

Unclear Roles Create More Than Employee Frustration

When a role is poorly defined, the problem spreads throughout the organization.

Hiring becomes inconsistent

Recruiters and managers begin selecting candidates based on different ideas of what the company needs.

One interviewer prioritizes technical experience. Another prioritizes customer service. The CEO wants leadership ability. The actual job mostly requires administrative execution.

Now you are not comparing candidates against one defined standard. You are comparing them against individual preferences.

Onboarding becomes guesswork

New employees receive different instructions depending on who trains them.

One manager says a task is urgent. Another says it is not part of the role. A coworker teaches an informal workaround because the actual procedure was never documented.

Then leadership becomes frustrated because the employee did not “figure it out.”

CEO, your onboarding process should not be an escape room.

Employees should not have to solve clues to discover what their jobs are.

Performance Management becomes subjective

When expectations are vague, performance discussions often rely on labels such as:

  • Not proactive enough
  • Not a team player
  • Lacks ownership
  • Has a bad attitude
  • Is not a good fit
  • Does not go above and beyond

But what specific expectation was not met?

What result was required?

When was it communicated?

How was it measured?

Was the same standard applied to comparable employees?

If leadership cannot answer those questions, the performance problem may be much harder to support than the manager believes.

Accountability becomes uneven

Unclear roles create duplicated work, dropped responsibilities, territorial disputes, and constant finger-pointing.

One employee believes another department owns the process. That department believes the manager is responsible. The manager assumes the employee should know what to do.

Meanwhile, the customer is waiting, the deadline is missed, and the CEO gets pulled back into a problem the system should have prevented.

Compensation and classification risks can increase

Poorly defined positions can also create wage-and-hour and classification concerns.

A title alone does not determine whether a position qualifies for an overtime exemption. The employee’s actual duties and the applicable legal requirements matter.

Calling someone a manager does not automatically make that employee exempt.

Calling someone an independent contractor does not automatically make the working relationship independent.

And adding major responsibilities without reviewing compensation, authority, workload, and classification can create problems that extend beyond morale.

Sometimes You Are Blaming the Employee for a System Failure

Now, I am not saying every performance issue is the company’s fault.

Employees still have responsibilities. They must communicate, learn, follow reasonable directions, and perform the work they accepted. But leadership also has a responsibility to create enough clarity for employees to succeed.

Sometimes the employee truly is not performing.

Other times, the company:

  • Hired without defining the outcomes.
  • Changed the role without communicating the changes.
  • Added responsibilities without removing anything.
  • Assigned two managers with conflicting expectations.
  • Failed to train the employee.
  • Never documented the workflow.
  • Measured performance using standards nobody explained.
  • Allowed the role to become whatever the loudest manager needed that week.

Then leadership says, “We keep hiring the wrong people.” Maybe. But if several capable employees have struggled in the same position, it is time to stop treating every departure as an individual failure. You may not have a people problem. You may have a role-design problem.

Warning Signs That Your Roles Are Not Clearly Defined

1. Employees frequently say, “I didn’t know that was my responsibility.”

That may be an accountability problem, but it may also mean responsibilities have never been clearly assigned.

2. Managers describe the same position differently.

If each manager gives a different answer about the role, employees will receive conflicting directions.

3. Job descriptions do not match the work being performed.

If the role has materially changed, the documentation, expectations, training, and possibly compensation or classification should be reviewed.

4. Performance reviews focus on personality instead of measurable results.

Terms such as “attitude,” “fit,” and “initiative” should not replace job-related expectations and observable facts.

5. The CEO must constantly decide who owns routine work.

If responsibilities repeatedly return to the CEO for clarification, the company has not established reliable decision rights and accountability.

What CEOs Should Put in Place Before Hiring Again

Before posting another opening, leadership should pause and define what the business actually needs.

Start with the business outcome

Do not begin with a recycled job description from another company. Ask:

  • What business problem should this role solve?
  • What results should the employee produce?
  • What work must be completed consistently?
  • How does the position support customers, operations, revenue, compliance, or growth?

Identify the essential functions

Separate the work that is fundamental to the position from occasional or marginal tasks. This becomes especially important when evaluating qualifications, performance expectations, staffing needs, and workplace accommodations.

Clarify responsibilities and boundaries

Document what the employee owns, what the manager owns, and what other departments own. Employees need to know:

  • What they can decide
  • What requires approval
  • What must be escalated
  • Who receives the handoff
  • Who is accountable for the final outcome

Define measurable expectations

Replace vague expectations with observable standards. Instead of saying, “Provide excellent customer service,” define what excellent service requires. Instead of saying, “Demonstrate leadership,” identify the decisions, behaviors, communication standards, and results expected from the manager. If you cannot explain what success looks like, you will struggle to evaluate whether it occurred.

Review compensation and classification

Compare the actual responsibilities with the compensation structure and applicable classification requirements. The title on the organization chart does not override the work being performed.

Build the onboarding plan before the person arrives

Identify:

  • What the employee must learn
  • Who will train them
  • Which procedures they must follow
  • Which tools and systems they need
  • What success should look like after 30, 60, and 90 days
  • When feedback will be provided

Hiring is not complete when the candidate accepts the offer. The company must still create the conditions for that person to perform.

Questions for the Exposed Growth CEO

CEO, I want you to ask yourself three questions:

  1. Do our current job descriptions reflect the work employees are actually performing?
  2. Would the employee, manager, and leadership team describe the purpose and expectations of each role the same way?
  3. Are we holding employees accountable to standards that were clearly defined, communicated, trained, and consistently applied?

If the answer to any of those questions is “I’m not sure,” that uncertainty is worth examining before you make another hire—or another termination.

The Real Leadership Lesson

Your company does not become structured simply because more people join it. Growth adds complexity. More employees mean more responsibilities, handoffs, managers, decisions, and opportunities for confusion.

If roles remain informal, the CEO eventually becomes the person who resolves every ownership dispute, approves every exception, and explains what everyone was apparently supposed to know. That is not delegation. That is founder dependency wearing a business-casual outfit. Clearly defined roles create:

  • Better hiring decisions
  • More consistent onboarding
  • Fairer performance management
  • Stronger accountability
  • Cleaner workflows
  • Better compensation decisions
  • More defensible employment practices
  • Less leadership confusion
  • Greater capacity for growth

This is not about creating rigid job descriptions that prevent employees from helping outside their usual responsibilities. It is about ensuring that flexibility does not become confusion—and that “other duties as assigned” does not become the company’s entire workforce strategy.

Let’s Consider…

If your business has 15 or more employees and you are experiencing repeated hiring problems, unclear responsibilities, inconsistent performance, management frustration, or constant questions about who owns what, the problem may be larger than one employee or one job description.

Your people infrastructure may not have kept pace with your growth.

Through my HR Consulting Services, I help growing employers evaluate their roles, responsibilities, job descriptions, workflows, manager expectations, documentation, and employee processes. We identify where the confusion begins and build practical HR structure that leadership and employees can actually use.

Schedule your HR Discovery Call here.

During our conversation, we will determine whether you are facing an isolated hiring problem—or whether unclear roles are exposing a larger breakdown in your HR and operational structure.

Stop hiring people into confusion and expecting clarity to magically appear after they start.

Define the role. Clarify the expectations. Equip the manager. Build the process.

Then hire the person who is genuinely qualified to succeed in the job your business actually needs. Because sometimes you do not keep hiring the wrong employees. Sometimes you keep hiring good people into poorly designed roles. And that is a leadership problem your business can correct.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.